Species #31 and 32: Lake Sturgeon and Flathead Catfish

It has been quite a while since I last caught a new fish species. My previous addition to the list was a Golden Redhorse on July 29. Fortunately, that drought ended today.

To improve my chances of catching a Lake Sturgeon (a new fish for me), I hired a guide named Jarrad. Jarrad told me he has been guiding anglers on the Mississippi River and surrounding waters for 37 years. His business is called Rutting Ridge Outfitters. He helped me catch the Lake Sturgeon I was targeting, was extremely friendly, and taught me a number of things along the way.

Lake Sturgeon

Since we were scheduled to meet about 10 miles north of Winona at 6:30 a.m. (an hour drive from Rochester), I got up at 4:00 a.m. to make sure I arrived on time. I pulled in at about 6:20 and found Jarrad already there and ready to launch his boat.

I had envisioned a long boat ride to our fishing destination, but it turned out to be almost within sight of the launch. We fished near the upper end of Mississippi River Pool 5A, just below U.S. Lock and Dam No. 5. Jarrad explained that sturgeon like this area because food is constantly being carried downstream from the pool above the dam.

Although I was excited about the prospect of catching a Lake Sturgeon, I also felt a little apprehensive. The forecast called for temperatures above 90°F, and I have experienced heat exhaustion—and possibly heatstroke—a couple of times in my life.

One incident occurred many years ago when my brother, his best friend, my best friend, and I went hiking in Canyonlands National Park in Utah. We lost our way and ran out of water before finally finding our way back to our vehicles. The nearest town, Moab, was about 60 miles away. By the time we got there, I was severely overheated. When I reached the hotel, I had dry heaves, but fortunately I recovered without lasting effects.

As it turned out, today was every bit as hot as predicted. There was virtually no wind and not a cloud in the sky. We managed by wearing hats, drinking plenty of water and Gatorade, and periodically soaking our shirts in the river and putting them back on. Even so, we decided to call it a day at about 11:30 a.m.

Our first Lake Sturgeon took only about 15 minutes to catch after we positioned ourselves near the dam. As the morning progressed, we landed three more Lake Sturgeon, two Flathead Catfish, and three Channel Catfish. Two of the sturgeon were estimated by Jarrad to weigh a little over 30 pounds. Both the Lake Sturgeon and Flathead Catfish were new species for me.

The Flathead Catfish and Channel Catfish were impressive fish as well, probably weighing between 10 and 20 pounds. In fact, with the exception of the first sturgeon, all of the fish we caught were likely larger than any fish I had ever caught previously. Before today, I don’t think I had ever landed a fish weighing more than about five pounds.

Flathead Catfish
Channel Catfish

Incidentally, Jarrad had recently suffered a painful accident. About a week before our trip, while we were making arrangements, he sent me a photograph showing stitches in two fingers on his right hand. He had accidentally cut off the tips of those fingers with a table saw. When I asked what had happened, he replied, “Table saw. The saw won.”

He is still learning how to adapt to tying knots and baiting hooks with his injured hand but appears to be doing very well with that. I ended up helping put quite a few nightcrawlers on the hooks throughout the day to be helpful.

I learned a lot from Jarrad. The fishing rig itself was entirely new to me. We used very heavy braided line—he didn’t specify the pound test, but I would guess it was somewhere between 50 and 100 pounds—along with an 8-ounce pyramid sinker and a massive 8/0 circle hook threaded with two or three nightcrawlers.

As I mentioned in an earlier post, fish essentially hook themselves on circle hooks. Unlike traditional hooks, there is no dramatic hook set. The fish takes the bait, turns away, and the hook catches in the corner of its mouth.

Another first for me was using a baitcasting reel. Most of the casting was done by Jarrad because he knew exactly where he wanted the bait positioned. I suspect he may also have been a little concerned that I would create a spectacular backlash, since I had never used a baitcasting reel before.

However, he did teach me the basics, and I probably made five casts on my own. He explained that you keep your thumb on the spool during the cast and then lightly feather the line as it leaves the reel to prevent tangles. He also showed me how to properly hold large fish for photographs: one hand on the tail and the other supporting the fish near the pectoral fins.

Overall, it was a very satisfying day. I added two new species to my list, caught several of the largest fish of my life, and learned a number of new things about fishing.

Gone Fishing: Management Buzzwords I’m Leaving Behind

I am retiring in October and, if all goes according to plan, will be spending a lot more time fishing and a lot less time in meetings.

That means I may soon be free from hearing some of the management expressions that seem to populate conference rooms, Zoom calls, and PowerPoint slides everywhere. Admittedly, I have used my fair share of them. Many of these phrases are harmless, but most can be translated into plain English.

Management SpeakPlain English
Circle backTalk about it later
BandwidthTime or capacity
Low-hanging fruitEasy opportunity
Value propositionWhy is this useful?
Stakeholder alignmentGet everyone to agree
Socialize the ideaGet reactions before deciding
In a vacuumIgnoring other factors
Move the needleMake a meaningful difference
LeverageUse
SynergyBenefit from working together
Actionable insightsUseful conclusions
Strategic initiativeImportant project
Best practiceProven method
Lean inBecome more involved
Drill downLook more closely
Take this offlineDiscuss separately
Parking lot that issueSave it for later
North starMain goal
Touch baseBriefly talk
OptimizeImprove
RobustGood/strong/reliable
Deep diveDetailed review
Align onAgree on
OperationalizePut into practice
Right-sizeReduce or adjust
At the end of the dayUltimately
Boil the oceanAttempt too much
Run it up the flagpoleSee what people think
Tiger teamSmall focused group
EcosystemCollection of related groups or systems
GranularDetailed
Thought partnerPerson to bounce idea

As for me, my main goal is simple: spend more time on the water, catch a few fish, and never again hear anyone talk about stakeholder alignment, synergies, or North Stars.

What the Heck are Barbels?

Having recently caught a ton of Bullheads and, just yesterday, a Lake Sturgeon, Channel Catfish, and Flathead Catfish, I became curious about the role these structures play in the lives of these fish.

Barbels (pronounced bar-buhls, not bar-bells) are the whisker-like appendages seen on catfish, bullheads, and several other kinds of fish. These structures help fish locate food in bottom sediments, murky water, deep water, and nighttime conditions where vision is limited.

Among North American freshwater fishes, barbels are found in many catfishes (Order Siluriformes), including Channel, Flathead, Blue, and White Catfish; Black, Brown, and Yellow Bullheads; and the numerous Madtom species. Barbels are also present in all true Sturgeons (Family Acipenseridae), including Lake, Pallid, Shovelnose, Atlantic, Shortnose, White, and Green Sturgeon. Other freshwater fishes with barbels include Burbot (also known as Eelpout) and Carp species such as Common Carp and Grass Carp.

Catfish typically possess four pairs of barbels (eight total), although the number and arrangement vary among species. Sturgeon, by contrast, always have four barbels positioned beneath the snout just in front of the mouth. Common Carp have two pairs of barbels (four total) at the corners of the mouth, while Burbot have only a single barbel located beneath the chin.

Although barbels have evolved independently in many different fish groups, they generally serve the same purpose: acting as highly sensitive sensory organs that help fish locate food and explore their surroundings when vision alone is not enough. From an evolutionary perspective, barbels provide a nice example of convergent evolution—different fish lineages independently evolved similar sensory “whiskers” because they offer a significant advantage in dark, muddy, or bottom-dwelling environments.

As a pathologist, I was curious about what a histologic section of a barbel would look like—that is, how it would appear under the microscope after staining. It turns out that a fish barbel is much more than a simple flap of skin; it is a highly specialized sensory organ.

In cross-section, a catfish or carp barbel typically contains:

  1. Stratified squamous epithelium covering the outer surface, much like the epidermis of human skin.
  2. Numerous taste buds scattered throughout the epithelium. In catfish, these are extraordinarily abundant. The taste buds contain specialized sensory receptor cells that allow the fish to literally “taste” objects before taking them into the mouth.
  3. Mucous cells, which secrete a protective mucus layer and help facilitate chemical sensing.
  4. A rich nerve plexus immediately beneath the epithelium. Large sensory nerve bundles course through the barbel, with individual nerve fibers extending to taste buds and tactile receptors.
  5. A connective tissue core that provides structural support.
  6. Numerous blood vessels that nourish the tissue.
  7. Supporting cartilage in some species.

Viewed histologically, a barbel resembles an exquisitely engineered sensory probe packed with receptors for touch and taste. What appears externally to be a simple whisker is actually one of the most sophisticated sensory structures found in fishes.

Now, when I look at a bullhead, catfish, sturgeon, or carp, I no longer see funny little whiskers—I see a set of highly specialized sensory instruments that help these fish thrive in environments where sight alone is not enough.

Fishing Near Home

In case you haven’t read any of my other posts, I live in Rochester, Minnesota. I’m a soon‑to‑be fully retired molecular pathologist. Over the years I developed genetic tests for diagnosing and guiding treatment for cancer—one example is a urine‑based test for detecting bladder cancer. With my team, I implemented these assays and signed them out to help oncologists and other physicians care for their patients. It’s been a rewarding career, but now it’s time to pursue my many hobbies, one of which is fishing.

I eventually hope to fish in places like Florida, Texas, and California to reach my 100‑species goal, but most days I’m content fishing close to home. Yesterday I woke up at 5 a.m. to get out before the heat—and because the early bird gets the fish.

I started in the tailwaters below the Silver Lake dam and caught a White Sucker, a Bluegill, and three Bullheads (likely black; next time I’ll check the barbel color more carefully to be sure). After that I headed to Foster Arend Lake to fish from the pier. Even at 8 a.m. it was crowded and already hot with no shade. I caught a good‑sized Bluegill, then decided to look for somewhere quieter.

That led me to explore a few places I’d never fished before. I drove north to Oronoco, a town of about 2,000 people roughly ten miles north of Rochester. The Middle Fork of the Zumbro River runs through town. In the 1930s a dam was built to create Lake Shady, a recreational impoundment upstream of downtown. The dam was heavily damaged by a flood in September 2010, and instead of rebuilding it, the city chose a river restoration approach—replacing the dam with a series of rock‑arch rapids. The project was completed in the mid‑2010s and even received engineering awards in 2019.

Middle Fork Zumbro River

Once I arrived, I found the area promising—potentially a good spot for redhorse. I used my usual rig: 6 lb line, a 1/4‑ounce egg sinker, bead, barrel swivel, about 15 inches of monofilament leader, and a size 8 hook. After about five casts I felt what seemed like a snag, but it turned out to be a nice sized Golden Redhorse. I would have stayed longer, but the heat was building and the morning was getting late, so I headed home.

Golden Redhorse

On the walk back to my car I noticed a beautiful Cardinal Flower—probably my favorite wildflower—growing along the path. A perfect ending to an enjoyable morning of fishing.

Cardinal Flower (in front) and Wild Bergamot (in back)

Making Sense of the Bewildering Array of Fish Hooks

As I’ve mentioned before, although I’ve fished on and off throughout my life, I wouldn’t consider myself an experienced angler. Over the past several months, I’ve been learning a great deal about the mechanics of fishing. One thing that quickly became apparent is the bewildering variety of hooks available. A visit to any sporting goods store reveals hooks of different sizes, shapes, and designs, with and without barbs. To better understand what works best in different situations, I decided to do a little homework. The figure below shows the basic anatomy of a fishing hook.

For freshwater fishing, there are roughly half a dozen major hook styles worth knowing. Manufacturers offer countless variations, but most are modifications of these basic designs.

Octopus hooks have a short shank, wide gap, and slightly turned eye. They are extremely versatile and work well with worms, leeches, and minnows for species such as bluegill, crappie, perch, trout, bass, and walleye. Some anglers argue that if you owned only one hook style, an octopus hook would be the best choice.

Baitholder hooks have a longer shank with small barbs along it that help keep worms and other natural baits from sliding off. They are especially useful for nightcrawlers and red worms. The tradeoff is that bait can be harder to remove and the hook is less versatile than an octopus hook. They are commonly used for panfish, perch, and trout.

Aberdeen hooks have a long shank and fine wire. They are ideal for fishing live minnows, particularly for crappies. Their thin wire causes minimal damage to bait, and the long shank makes hook removal easier. They can also sometimes be bent free from snags. The downside is that they can straighten under the strain of larger fish. They are effective for crappie, bluegill, and perch and are widely regarded as a classic Midwestern crappie hook.

Circle hooks have points that curve sharply inward toward the shank. They are most commonly used with live bait and passive presentations. Instead of a hard hookset, the fish effectively hooks itself as the line tightens. Their major advantage is a lower rate of deep-hooked fish, making catch-and-release easier. They are particularly popular for catfish and carp.

Worm hooks feature an offset bend near the eye and are designed primarily for rigging soft plastic worms and other artificial baits. They are a staple of bass fishing.

Treble hooks consist of three hooks joined together. They are commonly found on crankbaits, spoons, and spinners and are used for bass, walleye, trout, and pike. They are generally not used with natural bait.

Finally, fly-tying hooks are small, lightweight hooks specifically designed for tying artificial flies.

For the type of fishing I currently do, I have found that barbless octopus hooks in sizes 4, 6, and 8 handle most of the species I am targeting and simplify both hook removal and catch-and-release fishing.


Why I Don’t Own a Boat

My wife tells me not to tell this story.

It’s embarrassing, but I’ve always had a sense of humor about my mistakes, so I’m going to tell it anyway. It also helps explain why, in my quest to catch 100 different fish species, I do most—if not all—of my fishing from shore.

This happened a long time ago, in 2001. I was about 42 years old, and my son was 11. Within the previous year, I had purchased a new Ford F-150 pickup and a new boat, an 18-foot Rinker ski boat. I asked my son if he wanted to spend a weekend fishing in the Brainerd Lakes area of Minnesota.

He said yes, so we packed up and headed north. I think we stayed in a hotel on Friday night and planned to return home Saturday evening. I can’t remember the exact lake. There are so many beautiful lakes in that area, and after 25 years they all tend to blend together.

We launched the boat and spent most of the day fishing. Unfortunately, the fish were not cooperating. By mid-afternoon we had not had a single bite and decided to call it a day.

That decision turned out to be the easy part. The boat ramp was extremely steep. As I started pulling the boat out of the water, I heard a scraping sound. From the boat, my son immediately started yelling: “Dad! Stop! Stop! Stop!” I instantly realized my mistake. I had forgotten to trim the outboard motor up before pulling the boat out. I put the truck in park, got out, and went back to the boat to raise the motor. Unfortunately, instead of trimming the motor up, I somehow trimmed it down. That was all it took. The truck’s parking mechanism disengaged, and in an instant the truck began rolling backward down the steep boat ramp toward the lake. I jumped off the boat and made a desperate attempt to get back into the cab and put the truck in park. I didn’t make it. Instead, I fell hard onto the concrete ramp. Fortunately, I missed going under the wheels. Had things been only slightly different, this story might not be getting written. I injured my arm badly in the fall while the truck continued its journey into the lake. The truck ended up window‑deep in the water. Once water gets into the circuitry, the insurance company considers the vehicle totaled, and that’s exactly what happened. The boat sustained damage as well, although it was eventually repaired.

If there is anything funny about the story, it was what we found when we finally opened the driver’s door. About seven sunfish had somehow made their way into the cab of the truck. Those were the only fish we caught all day.

Because of my arm injury, an EMT was called. One of the EMTs was extraordinarily kind and put us up for the night since finding a hotel on short notice would have been difficult.

The whole experience was stressful at the time, but it has become one of those stories that gets funnier with each passing year.

What may surprise you is that I kept the boat for another five years. During that time, I had many enjoyable fishing and water-skiing adventures with both my son and daughter. Eventually, however, we sold it. That reminds me of the old saying that the two best days of a boat owner’s life are the day he buys the boat and the day he sells it.

Now that I’m 67 years old and even less confident in my boating abilities than I was at 42, I’ve decided that shore fishing suits me just fine. I don’t miss launching boats, loading boats, maintaining boats, insuring boats, or writing checks for new boats. I’ve also discovered that rivers often hold a greater variety of fish species than lakes, which is ideal for someone trying to reach 100 species.

That’s not to say I’ll never fish from a boat again. If a particular species requires one, I’ll gladly hire a guide or rent a boat.

St. Croix River

Drove to the St. Croix River early this morning hoping to pick up a few new redhorse species. I left at 4:30 a.m. so I could be fishing by 7, though the two‑hour drive always turns into a bit more with my usual pit stops.

I started at Osceola Landing with my standard setup: 6 lb line, a roughly 16‑inch leader, and a size 8 hook baited with a small piece of nightcrawler. I caught a small Freshwater Drum first, followed by a Golden Redhorse. Both were familiar species, so no new additions to the list.

The heat and lack of sleep caught up with me, so I took a 45‑minute nap and then grabbed lunch. That helped a lot. I spent the afternoon fishing at Interstate State Park on both the Minnesota and Wisconsin sides. I got a few bites but nothing hooked up, which was frustrating after such a long trip.

On the way home, I stopped in Hastings to try salvaging the day with a common carp. I did catch a fish there—but it turned out to be a large bullhead instead of a carp.

Not the day I hoped for, but still a couple fish and some new water and beautiful scenery explored.

Mississippi River Pools

Ever since I started fishing avidly in April, people have been giving me advice about which Mississippi River pool to fish for various species. If you want Bowfin, try this pool. If you want Sturgeon, try that pool. Looking for Walleye? Fish another pool.

I was vaguely familiar with Mississippi River pools but became curious about exactly what they were. I knew they were stretches of water associated with locks and dams on the Mississippi River, but surely they had not always been there. How many pools are there? Where are they located? And when were they built?

The Mississippi River pools begin in Minnesota, where the Mississippi River originates at Lake Itasca State Park. The pools are numbered consecutively as you travel downstream. The first Mississippi River navigation pool is Pool 1, located in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area. It extends from Lock and Dam 1 (the Ford Dam) upstream to St. Anthony Falls in Minneapolis.

A pool is the stretch of river between two locks and dams. Each lock and dam creates a backed-up section of river known as a pool. The pools are numbered in sequence as you move downstream. Pool 1 is in Minneapolis, Pool 2 is near St. Paul, Pool 3 is near Hastings, and Pool 4 includes Lake Pepin, one of the most popular fishing destinations in the Upper Midwest.

The last numbered Mississippi River navigation pool is Pool 26, located just north of St. Louis. South of Pool 26, the river becomes open river and flows freely all the way to the Gulf of Mexico without additional navigation pools.

Back in Mark Twain’s day, there were no Mississippi River pools. The Upper Mississippi was a free-flowing river with islands, side channels, wetlands, sandbars, and highly variable water levels. Commercial navigation was often difficult and sometimes impossible during periods of low water.

The locks and dams that created the pools were built primarily to provide a reliable 9-foot-deep navigation channel for commercial barge traffic between Minneapolis and St. Louis. The dams create deeper pools of water, while the locks act like elevators that raise and lower boats between pools of different elevations.

Most of the locks and dams that created Pools 1 through 26 were built during the 1930s, with the majority completed by 1940. A few notable exceptions include Lock and Dam 19 at Keokuk, Iowa (completed in 1913), Lock and Dam 1 in Minneapolis (1917), and Lock and Dam 2 (1930). The project transformed the river into what the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has called a “stairway of water,” with locks functioning as elevators that move boats and barges from one pool to the next.

The locks and dams have had both positive and negative effects on the river ecosystem.

Negative impacts include the loss of a free-flowing river, increased sedimentation in backwaters, altered fish habitats, changes to islands and side channels, and the spread of invasive species. The navigation system created a more connected waterway, making it easier for some invasive aquatic species to move throughout the river system.

On the Positive side, the locks and dams created a reliable commercial transportation corridor, which was their primary purpose. They reduced transportation costs and helped farmers and industries throughout the Midwest reach national and international markets. Construction of the system also provided thousands of jobs during the Great Depression.

The pools created recreational opportunities since stable water levels support boating, fishing, waterfowl hunting, birdwatching, and other outdoor activities. Although some natural river habitat was lost, the pools also created extensive backwaters, marshes, side channels, and aquatic vegetation beds that support many species of fish, migratory waterfowl, bald eagles, and other wildlife.

In addition, many river communities upgraded their sewage-treatment and drinking-water systems after the pools were created because water-quality problems became more apparent in slower-moving water.

Finally, while the lock-and-dam system was not designed for flood control, it does provide more predictable river conditions for navigation and recreation than existed before the dams were built.

Overall, the locks and dams transformed the Upper Mississippi from a shallow, often difficult-to-navigate river into a dependable transportation corridor while also creating many of the fisheries, backwaters, and recreational opportunities that anglers enjoy today. The trade-off was the loss of much of the river’s natural, free-flowing character. Many of the productive fishing areas that exist today are a direct result of the pool system, while many of the river’s original sandbars, islands, and natural channels have been altered or lost.

Fish Caught by Family (32 species)

Below is a running list of the fish I have caught, organized by family.

Centrarchidae (Sunfish family): 9 species

  • Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
  • Green sunfish (Lepomis cyanellus)
  • Pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus)
  • Rock bass (Ambloplites rupestris)
  • Largemouth bass (Micropterus nigricans)
  • Smallmouth bass (Micropterus dolomieu)
  • Alabama bass (Micropterus henshalli)
  • Black crappie (Pomoxis nigromaculatus
  • White crappie (Pomoxis annularis

Moronidae (Temperate bass family): 3 species

  • White bass (Morone chrysops)
  • Wiper (Morone chrysops × M. saxatilis)
  • Yellow bass (Morone mississippiensis)

Ictaluridae (North American freshwater catfish family): 3 species

  • Black bullhead (Ameiurus melas)
  • Yellow bullhead (Ameiurus natalis
  • Channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus)
  • Flathead catfish (Pylodictis olivaris)


Catostomidae (Sucker family): 4 species

Northern Hog Sucker (Hypentelium nigricans)

White Sucker (Catostomus commersonii)

Shorthead Redhorse (Moxostoma macrolepidotum)

Golden Redhorse (Moxostoma erythrurum

Acipenseridae (Sturgeon family): 1 species

Lake Sturgeon (Huso fulvescens)


Clupeidae: 1 species

American gizzard shad (Dorosoma cepedianum)

Esocidae (Pike family): 1 species

Northern pike (Esox lucius)

Leuciscidae (True Minnows, Shiners, Daces): 2 species

River Chub (Nocomis micropogon)

Common Shiner (Luxilus cornutus

Percidae (Perch family): 1 species

Yellow Perch (Perca flavescens)

Salmonidae (Trout, salmon, char, etc.): 5 species

Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss

Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis

Brown Trout (Salmo trutta)

Coastal Cutthroat Trout (Oncorhynchus clarkii clarkii)

Salmon spp.

Sciaenidae (Drum/Croaker family): 1 species

  • Freshwater drum (Aplodinotus grunniens)

Water Awareness


Since I started avidly fishing in April, I’ve become aware of the geography and character of water in a way I never had been before. I’ve lived in Rochester, MN for 37 years (with two years away), and of course I’ve always known the Zumbro and Root Rivers and the reservoirs — Willow Creek, East Kalmar, Silver Creek, Silver Lake, and South Landfill. Birdwatching made me familiar with the reservoirs over the years.

But when it came to the rivers themselves, I honestly couldn’t have told you much about their routes through the county. Now I find myself regularly thinking about them — where they flow, how they branch, and where good fishing might be. I’ve started paying attention to river features like riffles, runs, and pools, and imagining where each might be hiding fish.

The figure below shows the major watershed basins of Minnesota. The Cannon, Zumbro, and Root Rivers all fall within the Lower Mississippi River Basin, even though they aren’t individually labeled on the map. Seeing the basin laid out like this has helped me understand how these rivers fit into the larger landscape of southeastern Minnesota — and what species I might find as I explore them. Fishing has completely changed the way I see water.